Unit 5E at 1901 Walnut Street went on the market on September 22, 2025, at $599,000. Over the next eight months the price came down six times, to $549,900, $499,000, $449,000, $429,000, $405,000 and finally $397,000. It closed on July 31, 2026, at $372,500. A month earlier, Unit 15D in the same building had closed at $1,660,000.
Both units have the same lobby, the same door staff and the same 1925 Art Deco shell on Rittenhouse Square. Per square foot, 15D sold for nearly three times what 5E did. Rittenhouse Plaza sells in two tiers. A unit reaches the top tier only when it has three things together: height, frontage on the Square and a finished interior. A unit missing any one of them lands in a much lower band, and the co-op's monthly fee helps explain why that band sits so low.
Six sales, two prices per foot
These are the closed sales at Rittenhouse Plaza from February 2025 through August 2026, by price per square foot:
- Unit 15D sold June 29, 2026, for $1,660,000, about $692 a square foot for 2,400 square feet.
- Unit 2E sold August 31, 2026, for $630,000, about $358 a square foot for 1,758 square feet.
- Unit 6D sold February 21, 2025, for $755,000, about $351 a square foot for 2,150 square feet.
- Unit 17F sold July 27, 2026, for $400,000, about $327 a square foot for 1,225 square feet.
- Unit 20B sold November 17, 2025, for $275,000, about $297 a square foot for 925 square feet.
- Unit 5E sold July 31, 2026, for $372,500, about $241 a square foot for 1,545 square feet.
Five of the six cluster between $241 and $358 a foot. One sits at nearly double the top of that cluster. Square footage does not account for it, since 6D and 15D are within 250 feet of each other. The top three units by price per foot are all three-bedrooms, yet two of them sold for about half of 15D's figure.
What 15D had that the others did not
15D is a corner three-bedroom on the 15th floor with more than 70 feet of frontage on the park, 13 windows facing the Square, views to the east, south and west, a quartz island kitchen and updated baths. It had height, frontage on the Square and a finished interior, all three.
Each lower-tier sale was missing at least one of them.
Unit 2E was updated with its original architecture kept intact, with custom kitchen cabinetry, granite counters, a Jenn Air range and three oversized south-facing windows on the Square. It sits on the second floor, and it sold for $358 a foot.
Unit 6D overlooks the Square at treetop level, and its living room faces the park. It was marketed as an unrenovated unit for a buyer who wanted to design their own interior. It sold for $351 a foot.
Units 17F and 20B both have height. 17F is a high-floor corner with sunset views to the west and skyline views to the north and east. 20B is on the 20th floor with direct park views and southern exposure. Both were sold with original floors inlaid with mahogany and were offered to buyers as homes to customize. They sold for $327 and $297 a foot.
Unit 5E was freshly painted, with stone counters, an updated primary bath and views of both the park and the restored courtyard, all from the fifth floor. It sold for the lowest price per foot in the group.
These units vary widely in condition and layout. Some have been fully renovated or combined and others are largely original, so a building average says little about any one of them. Having one or two of the three features did not move a sale out of the lower band. Only the unit with all three did.
The fee does not fall in step with the price
The size of the drop between tiers comes from the monthly fee. Rittenhouse Plaza is a co-op, so the monthly fee includes real estate taxes along with heat, water and sewer, the doorman, insurance, building maintenance and management. Here are the fees each sold unit carried at listing. 6D carried $4,035.90 a month, 2E carried $3,136.34, 5E carried $2,751, and 15D carried $5,972. Per square foot, the lower and mid-floor units run about $1.78 to $1.88 a month, and 15D runs about $2.49. Fees are higher per foot on the upper floors, but they are substantial at every level, and they track size and floor rather than sale price. 5E's $2,751 fee on a $372,500 sale is not far from 2E's $3,136.34 on a $630,000 sale.
Compare a year of fees with the sale price. For 15D, twelve months at the listed fee comes to about $71,700, or roughly 4.3% of what the buyer paid. For 6D it is about $48,400, near 6.4% of its price. For 5E it is about $33,000, close to 9% of its $372,500 price. At 5E's listed fee, ten years of maintenance would come to about $330,000, nearly as much as the shares cost.
A buyer of an original-condition unit is pricing three costs together: the shares, a fee that does not scale down with the price, and a renovation the seller did not do. The fee and the renovation cost do not move when the asking price does, so the share price is the only part that can come down to make the total work. That is why lower-tier units here sell for so much less per foot than the top tier.
A condo on the Square is a useful comparison. Unit 1601 at The Rittenhouse, 1820 Rittenhouse Square, sold June 30, 2026, for $2,750,000, about $855 a square foot, with monthly dues of $3,107. Those dues are lower than 15D's fee on a far more expensive home, but condo dues do not include real estate taxes, which the owner pays separately. Comparing the two buildings by fee alone makes the co-op look more expensive than it is. Comparing them by price per foot makes it look cheaper than it is. Our earlier post on condo fees around Rittenhouse Square explains what those dues typically cover.
Price cuts were smaller in the top tier
The price histories point the same way. Five of the six sales above have a full price history, and all five closed below their first asking price. The size of the drop tracked the tier.
15D first listed briefly at $1,795,000 in March 2025 and was withdrawn. It came back in September 2025 at $1,895,000, was reduced in steps to $1,700,000, went under contract in May 2026 and closed at $1,660,000. That is about 12% below the September asking price. The lower-tier units came down further. 17F went from $475,000 to $400,000, about 16%. 20B went from $350,000 to $275,000 over about five months, about 21%. 6D listed at $985,000 in September 2024 and closed at $755,000 in February 2025, about 23% lower. 5E finished about 38% below its first price.
None of these units sold quickly. 6D, 20B and 17F each took roughly five to six months from listing to closing. 2E, the updated second-floor unit, was on one listing site for 452 days. In the lower tier, the first asking prices appear to have been set as if the fee and the renovation were not part of the buyer's total cost.
The building costs have largely been paid already
Building condition plays a small part in these unit prices, and that is because most of the building work is done. Rittenhouse Plaza was completed in 1925, designed by Henry D. Dagit & Sons, and has about 120 residences, 24-hour door staff and no on-site parking. When wet concrete poured onto the roof, terraces and west façade of the 21-story building, the co-op brought in conservators and masonry restorers to repair limestone sills, terra cotta, historic metals and roofing. The project earned recognition in the Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphia's 2025 Preservation Achievement Awards. Over the years the co-op has paid for repairs through recurring assessments, much of the major maintenance has been completed, and the private courtyard was recently restored.
Because the shared building is in good repair, the price differences come almost entirely from what is inside each unit and where it sits.
How to read the next listing
Unit 15A came on the market on October 12, 2026, at $1,595,000. It is a three-bedroom of 2,200 square feet on the 15th floor, updated with a Viking-equipped eat-in kitchen, a marble primary bath and views of Rittenhouse Square and the skyline. The asking price works out to about $725 a foot, with a monthly fee of $4,989.85. It has height and a finished interior. Whether it has 15D's frontage on the Square is the question its sale price will answer.
For any unit in the building, three checks place it in a tier: the floor, how much of the unit faces the Square, and whether the kitchen and baths are finished or original. Then add the monthly fee for the years you expect to own the unit, plus a realistic renovation budget, to the asking price, and compare that total with 15D's. Recent listings have also reported a $1,250 application fee and a transfer fee of 1% to 2% of the price, so confirm the current figures with building management before you make an offer. The figures in this post are general information drawn from recent listing records, not legal, tax or financial advice, so please confirm your own situation with the right professional.
Our Rittenhouse Plaza building page has more on the building, and our look at why the Rittenhouse Square median can mislead shows why building-by-building numbers tell you more than neighborhood ones.
If you are weighing a unit at 1901 Walnut, or deciding how to price one you own, Barbara Sontag Feldman can go through its floor, its frontage on the Square, its fee and its condition with you, alongside these recent sales, before anyone settles on a number. Let's Connect.